Choosing how to take gifts
Tap to pay on a phone, or a dedicated giving terminal?
Most phones can now take contactless payments with an app. Here’s an honest comparison with a dedicated giving terminal, so your church can choose what fits.
At a glance
Best for giving every week. At the collection and by the door or at the back of church, without anyone standing by.
Best for occasional, staffed giving. A summer fête, a coffee morning or a fundraising concert, with a volunteer taking each payment.
How they compare
Both take contactless cards and phone wallets securely. The differences are in who runs them, how they run, where they can go and what your donors see.
| Feature | GBx FlexGiving terminal | PhoneTap to pay app |
|---|---|---|
| For donors | ||
| Familiar and trusted by donors | A proper payment terminal, like the ones donors use every day | Tapping a card on someone else’s phone can feel uneasy |
| Donors choose their own amount | Preset amounts on screen | A volunteer types it in |
| Clear and natural to tap | On the front, where donors can see the screen | Often on the back of the phone, in a spot that varies by model |
| Fast, reliable card reading | Gifts processed in under 5 seconds | Reader strength varies by phone: 5 to 20 seconds per gift |
| Contactless cards and phone wallets | ||
| Chip and PIN | Some UK cards must be inserted | |
| Gift Aid built in | Donors scan a QR code | Not usually |
| Where it works | ||
| Works without anyone holding it | In a stand, podium, plate or basket | |
| Can be passed at the collection | In a GoodPlate or GoodBasket | |
| Takes gifts by the door or at the back of church, 24/7 | Kiosk mode, in a stand with a lock | Only while someone is there with it |
| Accessories made for it | Countertop and wall stands, podiums, GoodPlate, GoodBasket, banners, cases and lanyards. See them all | General phone cases and stands |
| Running it | ||
| Ready as soon as it’s switched on | Switch on and start fundraising | Download the app and sign in each time |
| A giving screen customised for your church | Your name, artwork and suggested amounts | The app’s standard payment screen |
| Works with no signal | Sends gifts once it reconnects | Limited, or not offered by some apps |
| Its own all-day battery | Up to 10 hours | Shared with the rest of the phone |
| A dedicated device, used only for giving | Runs GoodBox giving and nothing else | Also runs email, messages and other apps |
| Security and records | ||
| Secure card payments | PCI compliant to the highest standard | |
| Keeps donors’ details off personal phones | Details go only to the GoodBox Portal | |
| Records and receipts made for donations | GoodBox Portal, receipts by QR code | Sales reports made for shops |
| Cost | ||
| Nothing to buy up front | £199 plus VAT, plus £10 a month | |
Yes Partly No
Phone apps and their requirements vary by provider and change over time. GoodBox prices exclude VAT.
Pros and cons
Neither is right for every church. Here’s the short version.
GBx Flex giving terminal
Pros
- Switch it on and start fundraising
- Donors feel at ease giving on a proper payment terminal, not someone’s phone
- Donors choose their own amount, and gifts are processed in under 5 seconds
- Works at the collection in a GoodPlate or GoodBasket, and 24/7 in kiosk mode
- A giving screen customised with your church’s name, artwork and suggested amounts
- Dedicated accessories: stands, wall mounts, podiums, plates, baskets and banners
- Takes contactless, phone wallets, and chip and PIN
- Works offline, and is used only for giving
- Gift Aid, receipts and records made for donations
Cons
- £199 plus VAT per terminal, plus £10 a month
- One more device to charge and keep safe
Tap to pay on a phone
Pros
- Little or nothing to buy up front
- You can start the same day
- Easy to take to an event away from church
Cons
- The app has to be downloaded, and someone signed in, each time
- Some donors feel uneasy tapping their card on someone else’s phone
- Someone has to hold it and type in every amount
- Can’t be passed at the collection or left out by the door
- Often a volunteer’s own phone, so giving depends on them being there, and donor details end up on a personal device
- Some UK cards that need to be inserted are declined
- Shop-style screens and reports, with nothing built for donations or Gift Aid
Which is right for your church?
Think about where and how often people give, and who will be there to look after it.
A terminal is better if…
You want people to give at the collection every week, or by the door or at the back of church when nobody is around, with Gift Aid.
A phone is enough if…
Card giving is occasional, like a summer fête, a coffee morning or a fundraising concert, and a volunteer is happy to take each payment.
Some churches use both
A terminal for Sundays and the door, and a phone for the odd event away from church.
See the GBx Flex in church
How a giving terminal fits the collection and the rest of the week.
See the GBx Flex and all its accessories →
The GoodPlate and GoodBasket
The GBx Flex at the centre of a plate or basket, passed along the pews at the collection.
See the GoodPlate →See the GoodBasket →By the door, 24/7
Donation boxes that hold the GBx Flex in kiosk mode, ready for gifts day and night.
The GBx Countertop →The GoodBox Podium →Giving for your whole church
Artwork for your screens, how many terminals you need, and pricing.
Contactless giving for churches in the UK →Questions
If yours isn’t here, email sales@goodbox.com.
Can’t we just use the treasurer’s phone?
You can, and for an occasional event it may be all you need. The catch is that giving then depends on that person being there, with a charged phone and the app open. Most churches find that works for a one-off fundraiser but not for every Sunday.
Is tap to pay on a phone secure?
For card payments, yes. Phone payment apps are certified by the card schemes, and card numbers aren’t stored on the phone. The GBx Flex goes further: it’s PCI compliant to the highest standard and locked down so it only runs GoodBox giving, with no email, messages or other apps on it.
Is it a data protection problem to use a personal phone?
It can be. Card numbers are protected by the payment app, but other details aren’t: donors’ names, email addresses for receipts, Gift Aid declarations and the payment history can all sit on a volunteer’s own phone. Under UK GDPR your church is responsible for that data, so you’d need a policy for personal devices, a passcode on every phone, and a way to remove access when a volunteer moves on. With the GBx Flex, donors enter their own details on their own phones by QR code, and nothing personal is kept on a volunteer’s device.
Do donors need an app?
No, not for either. Donors simply tap a contactless card, phone or watch.
What if there’s no Wi-Fi in church?
A phone usually relies on its own mobile data, and offline payments are limited or not offered by some apps. The GBx Flex works offline when there’s no signal, and sends gifts once it reconnects.
Why are some cards declined on a phone?
In the UK, some card issuers ask for the card to be inserted and a PIN entered for extra security. A phone has no slot for a card, so it can’t complete those payments. The GBx Flex takes chip and PIN as well as contactless.
Can we use both?
Yes. Some churches use a terminal for the collection and by the door, and a phone for occasional events. GoodBox can help you work out what fits.
Not sure which fits?
Tell us how your church gives and we’ll help you choose, even if the answer is a phone. Or email sales@goodbox.com.